~ Forums of Enroth ~
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

~ Forums of Enroth ~

The Enroth diehard fan community
 
HomeHome  Latest imagesLatest images  SearchSearch  RegisterRegister  Log inLog in  
Latest topics
» Songs of Silence (HoMM like game)
[Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Icon_minitimeby Blake01 2024-03-27, 16:52

» Heroes Orchestra's 5th Birthday concerts with Paul Romero
[Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Icon_minitimeby rrravyn 2024-03-23, 22:45

» WARNING - The dreaded moment is here: Heroes 6 servers shutting down
[Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Icon_minitimeby Sir Albe 2024-03-22, 07:15

» fheroes2 General Announcements
[Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Icon_minitimeby sirDranik 2024-03-17, 23:35

» Photo Gallery
[Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Icon_minitimeby Sir Albe 2024-03-07, 06:57

» Polskie powitanie
[Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Icon_minitimeby rrravyn 2024-03-05, 04:02

» Heroes II localisation: how to make no-CD patch.
[Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Icon_minitimeby kiku 2024-02-19, 02:43

Poll
Global announcements should be:
Everlasting, 1 for each project.
[Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Redbar110%[Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Redbar12
 0% [ 0 ]
Temporary, when there is something new to announce.
[Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Redbar11100%[Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Redbar12
 100% [ 6 ]
Holalala... No idea where the Ultimate artifact is.
[Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Redbar110%[Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Redbar12
 0% [ 0 ]
Total Votes : 6
Most Viewed Topics
H3SW: General Graphics discussion
Ragoon's Graphics For HoMM3SW
Introduce yourself
H3SW General Discussion
H3SW Map List: Work in progress
H3SW: Dwelling Development
Forum Admins Feed
The Floody Land
Enrothian Fan Art
Heroes III: The Succession Wars v0.8.1 Beta

 

 [Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0

Go down 
5 posters
AuthorMessage
Unknown_Hero
Mage
Mage
Unknown_Hero


Messages : 778
Quality Points : 78
Registration Date : 2015-09-06

[Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Empty
PostSubject: [Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0   [Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Icon_minitime2020-08-09, 05:38

@ihhub

A few days ago, I went through the thread of ideas on Discord.

Why not stick with the original AI for now (I noticed that the current AI in fheroes2 is "weak"), at least until version 1.0 and focus on the other issues (bugs, etc.), so that the game is a faithful copy of the original game (but without the original bugs).

The AI upgrades can be added later and I think the player should be able to activate them optionally.
Some players will definitely want to keep the original feel of the game and be able to come back to it if they wish after playing with a different and enhanced AI.
In this way, all options remain open. Smile

Also, the predictable way the AI play in Heroes 2 is also part of the fun of playing Heroes 2.
And in Impossible mode, it makes it easier to beat the AI when it has the upper hand in a poorly started game.
Think about it. Smile
Back to top Go down
ihhub
Pikeman
Pikeman
ihhub


Messages : 42
Quality Points : 17
Registration Date : 2020-07-26

[Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Empty
PostSubject: Re: [Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0   [Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Icon_minitime2020-08-12, 02:54

We don't have the original AI in fheroes2 at all. The current AI is even worse than you can imagine. What we're trying to build is something similar to it with obvious fixes to make AI not dumb for certain situations in the game.
Back to top Go down
idsh
Peasant
Peasant
idsh


Messages : 1
Quality Points : 0
Registration Date : 2020-08-12

[Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Empty
PostSubject: Re: [Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0   [Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Icon_minitime2020-08-12, 03:12

Unknown_Hero wrote:

Why not stick with the original AI for now (I noticed that the current AI in fheroes2 is "weak"), at least until version 1.0 and focus on the other issues (bugs, etc.), so that the game is a faithful copy of the original game (but without the original bugs).

This option is not available.

Think of this as building a new house. Even if you have all blueprints and plans for the old house it would require the same effort of getting all materials and putting it together. FHeroes2 is not a mod, but complete rewrite that doesn't share code with the original game. Although we know original algorithms, it's not something you can copy and paste in. Smile

GodRage likes this post

Back to top Go down
Unknown_Hero
Mage
Mage
Unknown_Hero


Messages : 778
Quality Points : 78
Registration Date : 2015-09-06

[Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Empty
PostSubject: Re: [Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0   [Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Icon_minitime2020-08-12, 07:43

Hello ihhub and idsh,

So far, I haven't tested fheroes2 version 0.8 much to get a view of its AI.
I noticed that there were changes in behavior during the combats, but I haven't "analyzed" anything yet.

In the previous fheroes2 project, apart all the graphical issues, missing features, etc. the AI was already a big problem.
After the few games of the discovery, there wasn't much of a challenge in playing the game.
So players were going back to the good ol 'Heroes 2 which still holds up after all these years. Smile

The AI ​​in Heroes 2 is really fun to play. Wink
On the adventure map, the AI ​​heroes harass the human player throughout the game, constantly recapturing mines, attacking the weak heroes, if the AI ​​sees the opportunity to win the game, it does not hesitate one second and the player swings into the cage. Very Happy

During combat, the AI ​​is predictable, but this is also what makes its charm because the human player can thus defeat enemy armies much more powerful than his own and this is sometimes the only way to win a game when the AI players have more creatures and resources than the human player.
It can also happen that an AI hero destroys your magnificent army with a great blow of Armageddon, and the human player has to deploy treasure tricks to return to the same level of power that he has before.
In short, I find the AI ​​of Heroes 2 to be quite good.
And that's why I continue to play this game. Smile

I prefer the AI ​​of the adventure map in Heroes 2 to that of Heroes 3.
The AI ​​of the combats of Heroes 3 is a little better, but the combats of Heroes 3 seem endless especially with the possibility to make your troops wait.
The combats of Heroes 2 are fast and dynamic, it cuts and it bleeds all the time. Very Happy

Thank you both for your explanations.
Knowing the AI ​​algorithms of Heroes 2 is already a big plus.
I hope you will succeed in developing a good AI.
I think this is essential for the success of the project and that if you can recreate an AI quite similar to that of Heroes 2, it's all good for the future. Smile

GodRage likes this post

Back to top Go down
sirDranik
Nomad
Nomad
sirDranik


Messages : 94
Quality Points : 26
Registration Date : 2020-07-29

[Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Empty
PostSubject: Re: [Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0   [Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Icon_minitime2020-08-13, 10:20

Hello, @everyone.
Currently our almighty team is working on AI, to make it best-of-the-best. Smile
I believe, after all improvements, choosing the difficuilty of the map won't change simply an amount of resources and army AI gets, but overall behaviour on a world map and in the battles! So, choosing the "normal", "hard" or "expert" difficuilties will bring us as much close to the initial HoMM2 AI, as it can. I hope this won't ruin our gameplay experience and fun with it.
Also, I hope, that "impossible" mode would bring playing experience to more hardcore and exciting level!
I wish, changing the difficuilty level would completely alter gameplay on an every single map in this game. Smile

GodRage likes this post

Back to top Go down
Unknown_Hero
Mage
Mage
Unknown_Hero


Messages : 778
Quality Points : 78
Registration Date : 2015-09-06

[Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Empty
PostSubject: Re: [Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0   [Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Icon_minitime2020-08-13, 20:49

Hello sirDranik,

I'm looking forward to try this new AI on impossible level and see how I could manage to kick its ass beat it fairly. Very Happy
Back to top Go down
sirDranik
Nomad
Nomad
sirDranik


Messages : 94
Quality Points : 26
Registration Date : 2020-07-29

[Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Empty
PostSubject: Re: [Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0   [Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Icon_minitime2020-08-13, 20:51

So am I, Unknown Hero. Wink
Back to top Go down
GodRage
Webmaster
Webmaster
GodRage


Messages : 1042
Quality Points : 228
Registration Date : 2009-09-21
Location : France

[Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Empty
PostSubject: Re: [Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0   [Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Icon_minitime2020-08-14, 12:12

sirDranik wrote:
Also, I hope, that "impossible" mode would bring playing experience to more hardcore and exciting level!
I would like to see that the IA can check what he will get there and there before acting. [Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 164599763
Most of players tend to save and reload for some locations, or before building a new level of the Mage guild. [Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 3293758093
So if the Impossible IA also use this "regular trick", that would be awesome. [Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 2551314513

________________________
~Lands of Enroth~
Back to top Go down
http://homm2.free.fr
Unknown_Hero
Mage
Mage
Unknown_Hero


Messages : 778
Quality Points : 78
Registration Date : 2015-09-06

[Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Empty
PostSubject: Re: [Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0   [Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Icon_minitime2020-08-14, 20:22

@GodRage

I think that it is already planned that the IA should act primarily according to its needs with the improved IA. Smile

GodRage likes this post

Back to top Go down
Sponsored content





[Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Empty
PostSubject: Re: [Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0   [Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0 Icon_minitime

Back to top Go down
 
[Fheroes2 1.0] AI For Fheroes2 1.0
Back to top 
Page 1 of 1
 Similar topics
-
» [Fheroes2] Graphics Tools For Fheroes2
» Feedback Changes i would like too see for Fheroes2 mod.
» [Fheroes2 0.8] Fheroes2 Launch Time
» [Fheroes2 1.0] Enhanced Fheroes2 Combat AI
» They talked about fheroes2!

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
~ Forums of Enroth ~ :: Game Engine Guild :: fheroes2 :: Enhancement Ideas-
Jump to: