~ Forums of Enroth ~

An Enroth diehard fan community
 
HomeHome  FAQFAQ  SearchSearch  RegisterRegister  Log inLog in  
Latest topics
» Project Ironfist announcements
Experimenting with the Well Icon_minitimeby Unknown_Hero 2019-09-17, 23:00

» [H3SW 0.8.1] Sisters to the Slaughter
Experimenting with the Well Icon_minitimeby YhyJasne 2019-09-15, 11:59

» The YouTube thread
Experimenting with the Well Icon_minitimeby Just~Another~Lemming 2019-09-13, 01:29

» H3SW Map List: Work in progress
Experimenting with the Well Icon_minitimeby Sir Albe 2019-09-09, 05:15

» How to install Project Ironfists?
Experimenting with the Well Icon_minitimeby might_makes_right 2019-09-05, 14:01

» Sorrow's End map freezes when I move starting hero to the right a few steps
Experimenting with the Well Icon_minitimeby might_makes_right 2019-09-05, 12:21

» [H3SW 0.8.1] Arna Road
Experimenting with the Well Icon_minitimeby GodRage 2019-09-01, 05:51

Poll
"Wait" in HoMM2?
Yes
Experimenting with the Well Redbar1180%Experimenting with the Well Redbar12
 80% [ 55 ]
No
Experimenting with the Well Redbar1120%Experimenting with the Well Redbar12
 20% [ 14 ]
Total Votes : 69
Most Viewed Topics
H3SW: General Graphics discussion
Ragoon's Graphics For HoMM3SW
H3SW General Discussion
H3SW: Dwelling Development
H3SW Map List: Work in progress
Heroes of Might and Magic 3: The Succession Wars - General info & Announcements
Heroes III: The Succession Wars v0.8.1 Beta
Welcome fellow Enrothians!
Enrothian Fan Art
H3SW Recruitment Point - Enroth Needs You!

Share
 

 Experimenting with the Well

Go down 
AuthorMessage
Kristo
Peasant
Peasant
Kristo

Messages : 4
Quality Points : 2
Registration Date : 2017-10-10
Location : Illinois, USA

Experimenting with the Well Empty
PostSubject: Experimenting with the Well   Experimenting with the Well Icon_minitime2018-02-21, 15:51

I've long had a theory that the Well is responsible for much of the imbalance between factions in Heroes II.  Two extra Peasants or Goblins per week basically don't matter, but two extra Dragons or Titans is a huge advantage.  Project Ironfist finally gave me the chance to try this out.  I've modified the code to disable the +2 growth from the Well, enabled with a new command-line switch /disable-well.

Disclaimer: I've not playtested this, so I fully expect to have to tweak this further.  If you'd like to try it out, the pull request is here: https://github.com/jkoppel/project-ironfist/pull/106
Back to top Go down
Darmani
Master Modder
Master Modder
Darmani

Messages : 244
Quality Points : 40
Registration Date : 2014-12-27

Experimenting with the Well Empty
PostSubject: Re: Experimenting with the Well   Experimenting with the Well Icon_minitime2018-02-23, 03:44

Nice work! I commented on your PR. I agree that the well is unbalancing; good chance we'll use a variant of this in the final version. We had made well-compensating changes in the precursor to Ironfist: https://www.celestialheavens.com/forum/7/8724
Back to top Go down
Kristo
Peasant
Peasant
Kristo

Messages : 4
Quality Points : 2
Registration Date : 2017-10-10
Location : Illinois, USA

Experimenting with the Well Empty
PostSubject: Re: Experimenting with the Well   Experimenting with the Well Icon_minitime2018-02-23, 18:48

Yep, I remember UndeadHalfOrc's balance mod. I used to play with a simplified version where I just set base Dragon and Titan growth to 0. That change alone made a big difference. Now that the hooks are in place, we should be able to make changes pretty easily. We can change the Well's behavior per faction or even per creature if need be.

One other idea I had was to make the Well's growth relative instead of absolute. For example, what if it was +50% growth instead of +2? Centaur growth goes from 8 to 12, Crusaders and Cyclopes 2 to 3, but Dragons and Titans would still be 1.
Back to top Go down
Darmani
Master Modder
Master Modder
Darmani

Messages : 244
Quality Points : 40
Registration Date : 2014-12-27

Experimenting with the Well Empty
PostSubject: Re: Experimenting with the Well   Experimenting with the Well Icon_minitime2018-02-24, 09:56

Hmmm. Interesting thought. That's kinda like how H3 does it.

Your change also has me thinking about the plague. You have me considering removing it as a feature altogether. It's a great example of anti-fun: http://forums.na.leagueoflegends.com/board/showthread.php?t=293417
Back to top Go down
rafter
Skeleton
Skeleton
rafter

Messages : 8
Quality Points : 0
Registration Date : 2016-12-12

Experimenting with the Well Empty
PostSubject: Re: Experimenting with the Well   Experimenting with the Well Icon_minitime2018-02-28, 16:05

To make the game - very difficult, I played Heroes 2 Gold, with increased prices of level 5 and level 6 creatures. I increased the prices of level 6- 4 times, and the price of level 5 - 2,5 times. The Black dragon is 17500 gold and 2 sulfur. But even so, if I have much gold, I use level 5 and level 6 creatures. Because 3 Black dragons do 150 damage, while 5 minotaurs do 50 damage. Cyclops costs 3750 gold and 1 crystal. But 4 Cyclops do 96 damage, while 6 Ogre lord do  42 damage. I think, the Base growth of all weak units must be increased for Balance. If you want the game to be hard and difficult, it is better to increase the weekly growth of the weak creatures, an not to decrease the growth of level 5 and 6 creatures. If you decrease the growth of level 6 creatures, the game will become easier. So the growth of lv.5 may become 7-8. The base growth of lv. 4 creatures may become- 10-12.
Back to top Go down
Unknown_Hero
Vampire
Vampire
Unknown_Hero

Messages : 472
Quality Points : 63
Registration Date : 2015-09-06

Experimenting with the Well Empty
PostSubject: Re: Experimenting with the Well   Experimenting with the Well Icon_minitime2018-09-05, 05:25

It's very interesting, it would be nice to be able to change the growth from the well by script and independently for each creature.

For example +1 growth for Titan, +2 growth for Archmage, +3 growth for Roc, etc.
Back to top Go down
celebrindae
Skeleton
Skeleton
celebrindae

Messages : 8
Quality Points : 4
Registration Date : 2018-09-06
Location : Czech Republic

Experimenting with the Well Empty
PostSubject: Re: Experimenting with the Well   Experimenting with the Well Icon_minitime2018-09-07, 21:08

In my opinion the +2 well is not good way. The difference between +2 low/high tier creatures is too big. Still I would be not so rash to compare titan and crusader growth to strictly say its too bad to be knight Wink
The different price of all units here plays great role too, as you will probably have enough gold to buy 4 crusaders every week for 4k GP, but 15k for 3 titans? Aside from other creatures?

So to determine proper well bonus...
Lets say, the price of all creatures is more or less balanced. (The peasants are an exception, they should be for free at most Very Happy ) I would propose, that one castle with statue should earn enough money to buy all creatures born each week with base growth value (8750GP). With well, weekly earnings should not be enough, so you have to support it with spare money. For example, new units of one knight-castle cost weekly 5500 GP / 7375 GP when upgraded. With well, its now 8540 GP / 11 665 GP when upgraded.

I would set the base growth 2/3/4/5/8/10 for a knight to the slightly higher value, 2/3/5/7/10/14, which means weekly cost 8655 GP. The well could then go with some +1/+1/+2/+3/+5/+7 values.

Its +50%, which would let you play with low tier creatures in stacks against high tier ones in mid/end games. This will probably set the game difficulty higher, as it will increase mortality rate in battles Exclamation
Back to top Go down
Unknown_Hero
Vampire
Vampire
Unknown_Hero

Messages : 472
Quality Points : 63
Registration Date : 2015-09-06

Experimenting with the Well Empty
PostSubject: Re: Experimenting with the Well   Experimenting with the Well Icon_minitime2018-09-07, 21:55

Yes, there are subtleties in Heroes 2, from small maps to very large maps, and so on.

This gives the game many ways to play and that makes it beautiful and replayable.

Yes, the Knight Castle is not always at a disadvantage and offers many strategies to explore depending on the situation.

Every player has his vision of how things should be changed, so a chance to change things in his own way would be welcome. Smile
Back to top Go down
Sponsored content




Experimenting with the Well Empty
PostSubject: Re: Experimenting with the Well   Experimenting with the Well Icon_minitime

Back to top Go down
 
Experimenting with the Well
Back to top 
Page 1 of 1

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
~ Forums of Enroth ~ :: Modding Guild :: Heroes of Might and Magic II: Project Ironfist-
Jump to: